Timmy Turner has to share his fairies with his new neighbor Chloe.

Timmy and Chloe go to the retirement home to visit Cat-Man. Cat-Man mistakes Chloe for his old sidekick and takes her on ridiculous hero duties, while Cosmo is stumped on what to give Wanda for their anniversary/Timmy wishes that his Dad could be the mayor of Dimmsdale, but all the attention of being the mayor's son could lead to the exposure of Cosmo and Wanda. Written by DeJon Diaz

Catman thinks Timmy has been kidnapped. He mistakes Chloe for Catgirl and enlists her help to save Timmy. Timmy wishes Dad was Mayor, but Timmy gets tortured by the paparazzi and risks having his fairies discovered.

Chloe wishes that her favorite cartoon characters, The Fair Bears, would come to life, but Timmy and Wanda aren't happy with this wish./Foop, Dark Laser, and Mr. Crocker find out that Timmy is weak without his fairies and they try to get him while he's weak. Written by DeJon Diaz

Chloe thinks she has a stress-caused rash and wishes to be a slacker, but Dimmsdale falls apart without her. Dad wants to catch a giant fish to win a trophy, but Chloe wishes all the fish could fight back.

Chloe's goodness is draining the Anti-Fairy World Wand. Foop disguises himself as a girl to try and break Chloe. Timmy takes Chloe to meet Mark Chang to prove to her that aliens really do exist.

Chloe wishes that an animal that looks oddly like Mr. Crocker would no longer be endangered./Timmy, Chloe and the fairies go inside Mr. Crocker to destroy the magical Fairy Flu germs Cosmo sneezed on him.

When Timmy and Chloe save Dark Laser's beloved pet, Flipsie, Dark Laser becomes bound to them as their bodyguard. Timmy and Chloe wish up a girlfriend for Mr. Crocker to get him off their backs.

Chloe decides to disguise Cosmo and Wanda as her pet blue-footed boobies, but Chloe's parents take Cosmo and Wanda back to the forest to return them to their natural habitat. So now, Timmy and Chloe must find Cosmo and Wanda before they get into any real danger. Written by DeJon Diaz