Alice falls in love with the past and has her first kiss. Kat starts a job with the local newspaper. Del deals with bittersweet memories attached to Colton's boat.

Kat and Elliot chaperone the high school's "Back to the '90s" dance. Alice searches for a piece of her past in the present day. Del says goodbye to more memories as a local landmark closes its doors.

Kat and Alice try to stop Jacob's disappearance. Del realizes the tragedy of Jacob was not hers alone, but the whole town's, and moves toward healing.