Mark and Andy return to Cavendish to visit their estranged father, who runs a tourist-trap museum out of his home. But as the brothers reacquaint themselves with their peculiar hometown, they get caught up in an ominous and threatening tradition.

Mark and Andy are cast in a production of Anne of Green Gables.

A wax statue of Canadian icon Fred Penner brings trouble to the museum and nearly drives Andy insane.

When Mark wants to borrow money, Andy convinces him to get a job. But when Mark takes work in a travelling carnival, he risks getting sucked into a lifestyle from which he may never return.

While in town to see a show, Mark, Andy and Molly get lost after dark in a dangerous Charlottetown neighbourhood. Now they have to run, hide and fight their way back to the tourist zone before they become victims of big city crime.

Mark convinces Andy to join the local Coven with him to have some fun. But when Andy fits in better than Mark, the latter starts a much more sinister Coven, threatening to ruin Andy's newfound group.

After Rollie suffers yet another heart attack, Andy hires a caregiver who seem perfect. But when her interest in Rollie becomes more than professional, Mark convinces Ruth to fight for her man.

Andy wonders what his life would be like without Mark, leading to a series of dark events that could change his life forever.