The Nightcap staff is adjusting to their new studio next to Dr. Oz, as well as an unexpected new co-worker, Davis Maxfield, sent by the network to do the exact same job as Staci. Davis ruffles feathers when he tells Staci to bump Julianna Margulies in favor of a YouTube unboxing star.

Alec and Hilaria Baldwin go out of their way to be empathetic when Staci reveals she had a minor cancerous mole removed. Staci confuses their kindness as sexual interest and propositions them for a threesome.

Staci is caught being a horrible person by Juju Chang's hidden camera show. Desperate to prove she's a good person, Staci gets herself in too deep when Brooke Shields pressures her and Kelly Rutherford into a dangerous drinking game.

Julianne Moore is shadowing Staci to prepare for a role in an indie film. Acting anything but natural, Staci goes on an awkward lunch date with Donny Deutsch. Todd consults Barbara Corcoran and Dr. Oz about donating his body fat to Jimmy for a cosmetic procedure.