Twenty musicians from across the country arrive looking for love and musical chemistry; two men try to serenade the same woman; Ryan gets caught in a love triangle; Plain White T's put on a private concert for a pair.

Jamie is torn between two men, but chooses one and goes on a date in Venice, Calif.; Bri and Chris deal with trust issues; two new arrivals become Brandon's admirers; the 11 unattached women try to get a rose from the eight available men.

Savannah discovers that Brandon may have been two-timing her with Julia; each couple is assigned a song and starts rehearsing; the anxious couples are stunned to see who will be judging their romantic and musical harmony.

One couple write a song together with the help of Joel Crouse; a shocking exit brings another romantic triangle into focus; Rachel Lindsay, Bryan Abasolo, Andy Grammer and Toni Braxton judge the contestants' performances at a club.

Chris and Bri serenade a couple at their wedding; Jamie and Trevor use an empty arena to share their feelings; Rudi and Matt join Shaggy on stage; judges Arie and Lauren Luyendyk, Ashlee Simpson-Ross and Evan Ross, and Pat Monahan.