The NYPD identifies a dead girl in Central Park as Jennifer Levin. The search for her killer leads to her prep school friend Robert Chambers.

Robert confesses he killed Jennifer Levin accidentally during rough sex. His mother hires a high-profile attorney who says Jennifer was the aggressor.

Robert's preppy persona begins to crumble. When the Church steps in to support Robert, the Judge releases him on bail.

The media jumps on the defense's strategy to make Jennifer seem fast and loose. The prosecution works to establish motive.

Both sides present their cases. Jurors are mesmerized by Robert's charisma. Afraid Robert has charmed them, the prosecution offers a plea deal.